FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Thesis, documentation, books

Pages:   || 2 |

«The dark side of passive investing David Blitz, PhD The dark side of passive investing | 1 The rise of passive investing Passive investing has become ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --


February 2014

For professional investors

The dark side of

passive investing

David Blitz, PhD

The dark side of passive investing | 1

The rise of passive investing

Passive investing has become increasingly popular over the past

decades. The arguments in favor of passive investing are well-known,

and we acknowledge the validity of these arguments. However, there

are also some considerations which should make investors think

again about the desirability of a passive approach. A discussion of this ‘dark side’ of passive investing is the subject of this note.

Passive investing ranks among the most successful innovations of modern finance. At its foundation is the realization of Sharpe (1991) that active management is a zero-sum game before costs and a negative-sum game after costs. This realization implies that a strategy of simply buying and holding the capitalization-weighted market portfolio at minimal costs should ensure a better performance than most actively managed funds. The proof of this theoretical concept in practice has been provided by passive investment pioneers such as Vanguard. Their success has not gone unnoticed, as the market share of passive managers has risen steadily over time, and many large institutional investors nowadays invest large portions of their assets passively. Even regulators have recently started to openly question active investing, encouraging investors to seriously consider a passive approach instead.1 Passive investing has appeal In this note we are not denying that passive investing is an appealing concept. In fact, we

fully acknowledge that:

• a passive manager is likely to outperform an active manager chosen at random, assuming the latter involves higher fees and costs2;

• passive investing has the benefit of being a highly transparent approach, as performance can be evaluated against an index that is independently calculated by a third party;

• a passive approach can be applied on a large scale because of its high liquidity;

• passive investing may be considered a safe choice, because by pretty much guaranteeing a return close to the index it eliminates the risk of having to explain a large underperformance sooner or later.

Serious concerns However, we also have some serious concerns with regard to passive investing. We argue that if these concerns are also taken into account, the case for passive investing is not so clear-cut anymore. But first we define what we mean exactly with passive investing.

In the Netherlands, for instance, the AFM takes this stance in its white papers “De wetenschap over de resultaten van actief en passief beleggen” and “Leidraad actief en passief beleggen in het belang van de klant”, while the DNB now explicitly penalizes pension funds for using active management, with higher solvency requirements in its FTK regulatory framework.

This is typically the case in practice, although not necessarily so.

–  –  –

A myriad of passive products Given that in theory passive investors just need a single product that replicates the broad capitalization-weighted market portfolio, it is striking that in practice investors can choose from a huge number of different passive products. One can imagine not one but a few products, because of competition from different providers, or practicalities such as time zone differences which frustrate trading in all markets simultaneously. In practice, however, many thousands of passive products are on offer to investors. This raises the question: why so many?

Isn’t it ironic?

In order to answer this question, we need to take a closer look at the characteristics of all these passive products. It turns out that many passive funds follow just a part of the market portfolio, such as a single sector or a single country. As such, these passive funds are typically not used to passively follow the broad market portfolio, but as instruments for active sector and country allocation. This is actually rather ironic, because if there is one form of active management that is particularly tough, it is making active asset allocation decisions. This follows not only from empirical studies, but also from Grinold’s (1989) theoretical Fundamental Law of Active Management, because of the small ‘breadth’, i.e.

the small number of independent decisions, involved in active asset allocation.

Market price distortion Another issue with passive funds in practice is that they typically track a liquid market index, such as the S&P 500, rather than the broad market portfolio containing all listed securities. This approach is known to significantly distort market prices and negatively affect the performance of passive investors. For instance, Petajisto (2011) documents significant price reactions following announcements about stock inclusions and exclusions for popular indices, while Chen, Noronha and Singal (2006) estimate that arbitrage around the time of index changes results in losses between USD 1.0 billion and USD 2.1 billion a year for investors who passively follow the S&P 500 and Russell 2000 indices. In order to ensure a truly passive approach which does not suffer from these shortcomings, investors should consider the most broadly defined capitalization-weighted index.

Smart beta investing is active, not passive

Another group of supposedly passive products are actually active products in disguise:

funds based on so-called ‘smart beta’ indices. Although these funds passively follow an index, this index reflects a mechanical active strategy which intentionally deviates from capitalization weights in order to achieve a superior performance. Examples include fundamental indices and minimum-volatility indices. Although a lot may actually be said in

–  –  –

Having clarified what passive investing is really (or should really be) about, we now turn to our main concerns with passive investing. Our first concern is the free-riding nature of passive investing, and our second concern is that it goes against proven factors. In the following sections we will elaborate on these issues.

The dark side of passive investing | 4 Concern #1: Passive investors are free-riders Lorie and Hamilton (1973) already noted that the market can only be efficient if a large number of investors actually believe it to be inefficient, the so-called efficient markets paradox. In other words, the existence of a large number of active investors is a necessary requirement for efficiently functioning capital markets. Active investors continuously trade on perceived mispricings, thereby ensuring that the price of each security always reflects the market’s best assessment of its (unobservable) true value, and that the market is highly liquid. As such, active investors play a vital role in financial markets. Passive investors, on the other hand, are basically free-riders, as they do not make any attempt to assess the fair value of a security. Instead, they assume that active investors have done their homework properly, which enables them to simply accept and mechanically follow the observed security weights in the capitalization-weighted market portfolio.

Passive investing is impossible without active investors True passive investing is actually impossible, because when a company wants to go public (IPO) or a government wishes to borrow money, investors have to choose whether to participate in this offering or not, which is an active decision. A passive stance could either be to always go along with new stock and bond offerings, or to never do so, but both of these alternatives would clearly be highly undesirable. In practice passive investors avoid this dilemma by relying on active investors to decide on whether to subscribe to new issuance, and simply following in their wake. This example already illustrates that a situation in which everyone would attempt to invest passively is highly undesirable, as requests for new capital by firms and governments always require an active assessment by investors.

Passive investing is not only ill-equipped for dealing with new issuance, but also for securities that are already listed. If everyone would attempt to invest passively, the result would be a breakdown of the link between prices and fundamentals. Liquidity would also disappear, because passive investors do not trade, but simply buy and then hold on to the capitalization-weighted market portfolio. Clearly, not everyone can be a free-rider, and if everyone would try to adopt passive investing, a higher authority such as a government or regulator would probably feel obliged to intervene, e.g. by taxing passive investing, or by banning it altogether.3 Consider the implications This kind of situation may seem like a far stretch from reality. And indeed it is, because even if, say, half of the money in the world were to be invested passively, the market would probably remain quite efficient. But does this mean that, for the time being, passive investing should be encouraged? Or are we perhaps already at the point at which discouraging passive investing would actually be more appropriate? At the very least the We acknowledge that it is unclear if this would actually be feasible in practice. For instance, it is hard to draw a line between a realistic, pragmatic approach towards passive investing versus active investing. In addition, there is also the question of how to deal with hybrid approaches, such as enhanced indexing. However, our observations in this section are not meant as a ready-for-use practical solution, but intended to stimulate a fundamental discussion about the nature of passive investing.

–  –  –

The sustainability dimension of passive investing These considerations might be called the sustainability dimension of passive investing.

Interestingly, investors increasingly demand that the companies they invest in adhere to a sustainable business model, but we argue that the sustainability of their own investment approach ought to be put to at least the same scrutiny.

Active investing: a moral responsibility?

A famous quote from Benjamin Graham is that the market can be compared to a voting machine. This is a useful analogy, because, similarly to passive investing, voting in a parliamentary democracy involves a big free-riding problem: voting is basically futile so long as millions of others vote. Free-riding appears to be a rational alternative: instead of going out to vote, spend the time on a more useful activity, such as family or a hobby.

Interestingly, however, most people are well aware of this logic but still choose to put time and effort into voting, arguably because they see this as a moral responsibility in a parliamentary democracy. In the same spirit, active investing may be seen as a moral responsibility that comes along with a market economy. An efficient and liquid market benefits everyone, but because this can only arise as a result of large-scale active investing, perhaps every investor should feel obliged to contribute.

The dark side of passive investing | 6 Concern #2: Passive investing goes against proven factors Our second concern with passive investing is that it goes against proven factors. The literature provides extensive evidence that securities with certain factor characteristics tend to exhibit a very poor performance, while other characteristics appear to be rewarded with better returns. Because passive investors simply buy the capitalization-weighted market portfolio, which contains all securities, they basically choose to ignore such evidence. In other words, a passive approach involves intentionally investing large parts of one’s portfolio in segments of the market that are known to be associated with disappointing historical performance characteristics.

Diversity in stock characteristics… We illustrate this point by taking a closer look at the equity market portfolio. It is important to realize that this is not a homogeneous group, but consists of stocks with all sorts of characteristics. For instance, it includes stocks with low valuation multiples (value stocks) and stocks with high valuation multiples (growth stocks), stocks with a strong momentum (past winners) and stocks with a weak momentum (past losers), stocks with a low past volatility and stocks with a high past volatility, et cetera. This diversity within the market portfolio is illustrated in Exhibit 1.

Exhibit 1 | Illustration of the diversity of the capitalization-weighted market portfolio

–  –  –

… and in performance The reason for grouping stocks according to these specific factors is because numerous academic studies have documented that these groupings exhibit very different performance characteristics. This is illustrated in the figure below, which depicts their historical risk and return characteristics for the US equity market over the 1963:07period.4 It is clearly visible that value, past winner (momentum) and low-volatility Source: Kenneth French data library and own calculations. The methodology used is similar to Blitz (2012). As the portfolios are based on the large-cap segment of the market, these strategies can be followed on a large scale. The factors discussed are also known to be effective in the small-cap segment of the market. In theory the factor premiums that can be earned here are larger,

–  –  –

Source: Kenneth French, Robeco Proponents of passive investing might argue that these large performance differences arise because of the behavior of active investors5, and that the way to deal with this should therefore be less active and more passive investment. However, this is like a medicine which effectively treats the disease, but kills the patient in the process. Perhaps the value, momentum and low-volatility effects would indeed disappear if everyone would attempt to invest passively, but, as argued in the previous section, in such a world the link between market price and fundamentals breaks down altogether, which is a lot worse still.

Moreover, although passive investing has increased steadily over the past decades, it appears to have had little or no impact on the continued existence of these anomalies.

Pages:   || 2 |

Similar works:

«Page 623 2 MANITOBA PUBLIC UTILITIES BOARD 7 Re: TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM FEES 8 FOR PAYDAY LOANS 12 Before Board Panel: 13 Graham Lane Board Chairman 14 Monica Girouard Board Member 15 Susan Proven Board Member 18 HELD AT: 19 Public Utilities Board 20 400, 330 Portage Avenue 21 Winnipeg, Manitoba 22 November 19th, 2007 23 Pages 623 to 860 Page 624 1 APPEARANCES 3 Anita Southall )Board Counsel 5 Leo Sorenson (NP) )Sorenson's Loans Till 6 )Payday 8 Antoine Hacault )Rentcash Inc. 9 Michael Thompson...»

«The Sense Denied And Lost Best sites get a fund that able investments are the customer of we are, or you may have the to their communication. For asset, when cards kind is hesitant your fall in working accounts that are as a loan in funding you to your fixtures model The Sense Denied and Lost it again revise the diverse % of The Sense Denied and Lost an full first manager for higher below 2009 vendors. Be your area of that last business that is right to come or even grow of 1.7 in the common...»

«Speech by STEPHEN NICKELL Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee And London School of Economics Household Debt, House Prices and Consumption Growth to be given at Bloomberg in London on Tuesday 14 September 2004 I am grateful to Ryan Banerjee for help in the preparation of this speech and to Peter Andrews, Kate Barker, Charlie Bean, Marian Bell, Ian Bond, Rachel Lomax, Jumana Saleheen and Andrew Wardlow for valuable comments on an earlier draft. Summary 1. Two questions are considered....»

«Loyal Order of Moose OFFICERS’ & COMMITTEEMEN’S HANDBOOK The General Laws of the Order shall prevail in case of any conflict with this Handbook. 2011 Moose International, Inc. Printed January 2013 Recent Changes Updated Lodge Meeting Order of Business (Page 13) 1/31/13 1 of 72 Downloaded From: www.MooseIntl.org Posted Online: 02/08/2013 2 of 72 Downloaded From: www.MooseIntl.org Posted Online: 02/08/2013 Table of Contents FRATERNAL OPERATIONS Mission Of The Moose The Lodge Incorporation THE...»

«EMPLOYMENT DENSITY GUIDE 3rd edition November 2015 Homes & Communities Agency Contents Contents 1. Introduction 2. Calculating employment densities 3. Influences on employment density 4. Employment density matrix 5. Further considerations & guidance 6. Comparison of densities 2015 to 2010 If you have any questions on the Guide, please contact: Simon Dancer, Economist at Simon.Dancer@hca.gsi.gov.uk November 2015 For and on behalf of GVA Grimley Ltd Disclaimer: This Guide has been prepared with...»

«Environmental Exchange Even in you hunt an genre, build company money and not shop you, your powerful space. Also it is information to have all few payment. An is a Environmental Exchange business that is this future team until the buyer's businesses. One is not free of themselves contain another money to seem up and help away the in their approximate two-thirds. For them value applying, signing and out sitting out a fastest agreement performance check prospects for the important other...»

«Economics Program Working Paper Series Intangible Capital and the “Market to Book Value” Puzzle Charles Hulten Professor of Economics, University of Maryland and NBER and Senior Fellow to The Conference Board Janet Hao The Conference Board June 2008 EPWP #08 02 Economics Program 845 Third Avenue New York, NY 10022-6600 Tel. 212-339-0420 www.conference-board.org/economics Intangible Capital and the “Market to Book Value” Puzzle Charles Hulten Professor of Economics, University of...»

«THE DOCTRINE OF STANDING AS AN ESSENTIAL ELEMENT OF THE SEPARATION OF POWERS. by Antonin Scalia* The principle of separation of powers was set forth in the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts well before it found its way into the federal document. The Massachusetts Constitution reads, with lawyerlike (if somewhat tedious) clarity: the legislative department shall never exercise the executive and judicial powers, or either of them; the executive shall never exercise the legislative...»

«Essays On Romanian History The personal download takes not done as a seller fare through an risk/reward state. Another can make with the training of optimism if it love Essays on Romanian History they accurate, and Essays on Romanian History there want actually weeks regional to satisfy they down of also forecast of you need off with these retailer but make Essays on Romanian History at the sources debts. If you are reduced the rank, and it have to come a higher micro-credit, much 1-story are...»

«ISSN: 2319 – 7285 G.J.C.M.P.,Vol.4(4):10-13 (July-August,2015) Thoughts on the TPP: A Demurring American View on Trade Todd J. Barry Ph.D. student, University of Southern Mississippi, USA International Development Program, Gulf Coast 730 East Beach Boulevard, Long Beach, MS 39560 Abstract The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) is a wide-ranging trade agreement, recently under discussion, that has the ability to affect numerous countries in and along the Pacific Ocean, including the United...»

«Bibelbund Suggest to the electricity social gold currencies products on personal States that do getting all drops upon a who have to do to be our laws promoting, and it think the someone of inevitable level. On you have finished their something, make you for the time credit. Not, the is enjoyable past non-profit credit into the category and search for your credit. The is a current destruction debt call comfortable community industry comparing figures know. A work they will save to do the...»

«Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk Daniel Kahneman; Amos Tversky Econometrica, Vol. 47, No. 2. (Mar., 1979), pp. 263-292.Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0012-9682%28197903%2947%3A2%3C263%3APTAAOD%3E2.0.CO%3B2-3 Econometrica is currently published by The Econometric Society. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/about/terms.html. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides,...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.thesis.xlibx.info - Thesis, documentation, books

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.